Westworld-Reviews: Gut bis sehr gut mit ein paar Macken

Gepostet vor 2 Monaten, 12 Tagen in Movies Share: Twitter Facebook Mail

wworld

Seit gestern erscheinen die ersten Reviews zu HBOs Serien-Remake von Westworld, die am Sonntag, 2. Oktober auf HBO startet (bei uns auf Sky Go und Sky on Demand). Tenor so ungefähr: Gut bis sehr gut mit ein paar Macken.

Hier erstmal die kritischsten Reviews von Variety und AV Club:

Variety: „Part of the problem with 'Westworld', oddly enough, is that the actors playing the hosts are often quite magnetic. […] the discussion about whether the hosts have attained consciousness seem somewhat pointless: To the audience, they obviously have. […] 'Westworld' doesn’t want to alienate any potential customers, so it draws on a grab bag of ideas and clashing tones without making its point of view clear. The more indistinct a concept, the fewer people can take issue with it, which is an approach that might work well for a vacation spot, but poses a serious problem for an ambitious television drama.“

AV Club: „To endure as a TV series, Westworld will need to bridge the gap between its fascinating ideas and the blank canvases they’re projected upon. Fortunately, it’s not so lost in its thoughts to forget that a robot-cowboy show ought to have the occasional shootout, heist, or daring escape. And while it’s never as plainly satirical as the original film, it still exhibits a sense of humor. Now it just needs to provide compelling reasons to care whether these characters live, die, or wake up to the truth of their reality.“

Die restlichen Reviews sind beinahe schon euphorisch, ich denke, wir haben ’nen Gewinner (und ja, Wowcast ist fest geplant).

Hollywood Reporter: „Westworld as a series is a big idea with more mythology than a handful of episodes truly uncover — which is a positive sign. It's better to be difficult than to be flimsy and disappointingly easy to figure out. The challenges in Westworld make it worth the investment.“

Telegraph: „we’re thrust into a complex, visionary world that is pleasingly in no rush to rapidly churn out its storyline. Like the on-screen robots, its pieces are meticulously put together, its capacity to unleash hell brimming beneath the surface. And it’s beautiful to watch.“

Guardian: „Westworld will hit the spot as hard as GoT ever did. Gosh, there’s a lot going on. There’s the real world full of robot-wranglers, some of whom are jostling for position inside whatever just-possibly-malevolent company owns the park, others of whom are busy tinkering with their charges’ software and trying to decide whether to make the skinjobs more realistic or quit while they’re ahead.“

spOnline: „Die Vielschichtigkeit des sich romanhaft entblätternden Plots und die Intellektualität der verhandelten Fragen hebt 'Westworld' über vergleichbare aktuelle Serien hinaus: - Es geht um Bewusstsein und Identität, um menschliche Profitgier und Hybris sowie um die moralischen Fallstricke technischer Machbarkeit. "High Noon" für die conditio humana.“

Screen Crush: „'The Original' intriguingly sets the stage for what is, I presume, a season-long arc involving Ed Harris’ mysterious Gunslinger. Unlike Yul Brenner’s sinister A.I. in Crichton’s film, Harris’ version is far more enigmatic. Though what he is exactly is never made explicit, he does have a sense of self-awareness, and Harris’ Gunslinger mostly serves as an agent of chaos — a devious pot-stirrer who knows how to avoid detection, lest he be taken out of commission by the powers-that-be.“

Tags: Series Westworld

wwwwwwwwwwaaa

Wowcast 84: Westworld-Finale – The Bicameral Mind

Im 84. Wowcast besprechen wir das großartige Finale von Westworld, leider bis 2018 unser letzter Podcast über die fantastische Serie…

cy9ezs_xgae4ltx

Black Mirror als EC-Comic-Cover

Butcher Billys neueste Illus: Black Mirror im Stil alter EC-Comics (und ein paar weitere Motive mit Milch-Moss und Satans-Zuck). Ich…

bildschirmfoto-2016-12-04-um-09-52-34

Westworld x Pulp Fiction

Dolores will execute every motherfucking last one of ya, if any of you fucking pricks move. (Ich hätte das gerne…

ww1

Wowcast 83: Die große Westworld-Aufholjagd

Im 83. Wowcast besprechen wir - puh! - den ganzen Rest von Westworld vor dem großen Finale am Sonntag, den…

ww

Westworld Version 4.5.2 Patch Notes

McSweeney mit dem ReadMe.txt des letzten Westworld-Updates. Die Hosts haben jetzt größere Hüte, die besser riechen. Ein paar Favs: GENERAL…

bildschirmfoto-2016-11-22-um-09-41-39

Netflix Retina-BlackMirror Ad

„The question is not if you want this, but are you ready for it?“

Every Episode of Black Mirror

McSweeneys ❤️ Every Episode of Black Mirror. “Technology,” she says. “Internet,” he replies. She opens an app and the futuristic…

bm

Every Black Mirror-Episode, ranked

Hervorragendes Ranking aller Black Mirror-Folgen von Clickhole-Schreiber Brian Boone, dem ich noch ein „All the Smart-Lenses turn into Googly Eyes,…

ww1

Wowcast 81: Westworld 1x4/5 – Dissonance Theory/Contrapasso

Im 81. Wowcast besprechen wir die vierte und fünfte Episode der existenzialistischen Robotcowboy-Mystery-SciFi-Serie mit Riesenbagger: Westworld, Folge 4: Dissonance Theory…

bm1

Wowcast 80: Black Mirror 3x4/5/6 – San Junipero, Men Against Fire, Hated in the Nation

Im 80. Wowcast besprechen wir die vierte, fünfte und sechste Episode – San Junipero, Men Against Fire und Hated in…

judge

Black Mirror-Ringtones, Brooker-AMA und die 80s als „Our Era“

Ich will mir mal kurz diese kleine Troll-Aktion von Black Mirror festhalten, die den 80s-Soundtrack zur vierten Episode der dritten…