Drumpf never just jokes

Gepostet vor 5 Monaten, 6 Tagen in #Politics #Science #Comedy #DonaldTrump

Share: Twitter Facebook Mail

lolBig News: Drumpf Tiny Hands hat etwas sehr dummes gesagt. Sensationell, ich weiß. In seinem neuesten Drumpf-Brain-Gone-Wrong-Anfall schlägt er vor, die „2nd Amendment-People“ könnten ja etwas dagegen tun, dass Hillary Clinton die Richter des Obersten Gerichtshofs wählt. Die „2nd Amendment-People“ sind die Verteidiger des amerikanischen Waffenrechts. Der Spruch wird (auch von mir) als „ironischer“ Vorschlag zur Tötung von Frau Clinton gelesen, Drumpfs Spruch wird von seinen Fans bereits damit verteidigt, er habe ja nur einen Witz gemacht. Diese Verteidigung – „es ist nur ein Witz“ – findet man auch oft in Debatten um Hatespeech, Trolle und Diskussionskultur im Netz.

Jason P. Steed hat seine Abschlussarbeit über die soziale Funktion von Humor geschrieben und erklärt nun in einem Twitter-Thread, warum Witze nie einfach „nur Witze“ sind, sondern immer in Beziehung zu anderen Menschen gerissen werden. Wenn Drumpf Tiny Hands also Witze über die Anwendung des amerikanischen Waffenrechts auf Hillary Clinton macht, dann ist das ein soziales Signal, genau wie meine konsequente Veralberung von Trump als johnoliverscher „Drumpf“ ein soziales Signal ist. Oder nochmal anders: For the Lulz is a myth. (via Philippe)

1. I wrote my PhD dissertation on the social function of humor (in literature & film) and here's the thing about "just joking."

2. You're never "just joking." Nobody is ever "just joking." Humor is a social act that performs a social function (always).

3. To say humor is social act is to say it is always in social context; we don't joke alone. Humor is a way we relate/interact with others.

4. Which is to say, humor is a way we construct identity - who we are in relation to others. We use humor to form groups...

5. ...and to find our individual place in or out of those groups. In short, joking/humor is one tool by which we assimilate or alienate.

6. IOW, we use humor to bring people into - or keep them out of - our social groups. This is what humor *does.* What it's for.

7. Consequently, how we use humor is tied up with ethics - who do we embrace, who do we shun, and how/why?

8. And the assimilating/alienating function of humor works not only only people but also on *ideas.* This is important.

9. This is why, e.g., racist "jokes" are bad. Not just because they serve to alienate certain people, but also because...

10. ...they serve to assimilate the idea of racism (the idea of alienating people based on their race). And so we come to Trump.

11. A racist joke sends a message to the in-group that racism is acceptable. (If you don't find it acceptable, you're in the out-group.)

12. The racist joke teller might say "just joking" - but this is a *defense* to the out-group. He doesn't have to say this to the in-group.

13. This is why we're never "just joking." To the in-group, no defense of the joke is needed; the idea conveyed is accepted/acceptable.

14. So, when Trump jokes about assassination or armed revolt, he's asking the in-group to assimilate/accept that idea. That's what jokes do.

15. And when he says "just joking," that's a defense offered to the out-group who was never meant to assimilate the idea in the first place.

16. Indeed, circling back to the start, the joke *itself* is a way to define in-group and out-group, through assimilation & alienation.

17. If you're willing to accept "just joking" as defense, you're willing to enter in-group where idea conveyed by the joke is acceptable.

18. IOW, if "just joking" excuses racist jokes, then in-group has accepted idea of racism as part of being in-group.

19. Same goes for "jokes" about armed revolt or assassinating Hillary Clinton. They cannot be accepted as "just joking."

20. Now, a big caveat: humor (like all language) is complicated and always a matter of interpretation. For example, we might have...

21. ...racist humor that is, in fact, designed to alienate (rather than assimilate) the idea of racism. (Think satire or parody.)

22. But I think it's pretty clear Trump was not engaging in some complex satirical form of humor. He was "just joking." In the worst sense.

23. Bottom line: don't accept "just joking" as excuse for what Trump said today. The in-group for that joke should be tiny. Like his hands.

sub-buzz-11018-1484342735-1

RechtsLinks 15. 1. 2017: Mapping Trumpworld, Correctiv vs Fake-News, Seeßlen über Trump und Populismus

Buzzfeed: Mapping Trumpworld: „We logged more than 1,500 people and organizations connected to the incoming administration.“ Netzpolitik: Facebook kündigt Maßnahmen…

cuckwork

Fake Books on the Subway: Trump Edition

Scott Rogowsky reads Fake Books again. This one is especially lulzworthy because Trump is a well-documented Non-Reader. And „Cuckwork Orange“…

acc

Life Accordion To Trump

„Sit back to the soothing tunes“ by @rabbitandcoffee.

gold2

Domald Tromp Pounded In The Butt By The Handsome Russian T-Rex Who Also Peed On His Butt And Then Blackmailed Him With The Videos Of His Butt Getting Peed On

Chuck Tingle did it again, it's about a golden Boy named Tromp because ofcourse: Domald Tromp Pounded In The Butt…

C17dedCUAAAskQZ

Links 12.1.2017: You are Fake News, we are fired, everyone is a partisan Identity-Designer of the Tribes

Washington Post: What the [fuck] happened at the Trump news conference? First, he has decided that his official position on…

thumbs_3354-w-gibson

William Gibson über die bizarre neue Realität

Sehr spannendes Gespräch von Jochen Wegner mit William Gibson über Trump und die „bizarre neue Realität“, in der wir leben:…

Trump Twitter Archive

Trump Twitter Archive

„The Trump Twitter Archive contains almost every tweet from @realdonaldtrump since he joined in 2009 and will remain current (within…

join

Resist! Anti-Trump Comic-Tabloid-Newspaper

Resist!, eine Zeitung voller politischer Comics von Françoise Mouly, Redakteurin beim New Yorker und ihrer Tochter, Nadja Spiegelman (ja, der…

gold2

Golden Boy

Buzzfeed veröffentlicht „A dossier, compiled by a person who has claimed to be a former British intelligence official, allege Russia…

pepe

International Diplomacy by Frog-Meme

Russia taunts British PM with cartoon frog tweet. Rarest of all Pepes – yet! – is International Diplomacy Pepe and…

bildschirmfoto-2017-01-09-um-13-00-24

Donald Trump vs Meryl Streep

Bei den Golden Globes hat Meryl Streep in einer langen Rede den Donald auseinandergenommen: „There was one performance this year…