H. G. Wells über Metropolis (1927)

Gepostet vor 6 Jahren, 9 Monaten in Misc Movies Share: Twitter Facebook Mail


SciFi-Autor H. G. Wells hat 1927 den Klassiker „Metropolis“ in der New York Times reviewt und die Rezension erinnert mich in vielen Punkten an die Kritiken an diesem anderen SciFi-Film namens „Avatar“, der in diesen Tagen oft für seine mangelnde Originalität kritisiert wird.

Die Zeit wird, und da bin ich mir sehr sicher, „Avatar“ zu einem Klassiker der Kinogeschichte machen, genau wie „Metropolis“. Ein Meilenstein ist er jetzt schon.

I have recently seen the silliest film.

I do not believe it would be possible to make one sillier.

And as this film sets out to display the way the world is going,

I think [my book] The Way the World is Going may very well concern itself with this film.

It is called Metropolis, it comes from the great Ufa studios in Germany, and the public is given to understand that it has been produced at enormous cost.

It gives in one eddying concentration almost every possible foolishness, cliché, platitude, and muddlement about mechanical progress and progress in general served up with a sauce of sentimentality that is all its own.

It is a German film and there have been some amazingly good German films, before they began to cultivate bad work under cover of a protective quota. And this film has been adapted to the Anglo-Saxon taste, and quite possibly it has suffered in the process, but even when every allowance has been made for that, there remains enough to convince the intelligent observer that most of its silliness must be fundamental.

Possibly I dislike this soupy whirlpool none the less because I find decaying fragments of my own juvenile work of thirty years ago, The Sleeper Awakes, floating about in it.

Capek's Robots have been lifted without apology, and that soulless mechanical monster of Mary Shelley's, who has fathered so many German inventions, breeds once more in this confusion.

Originality there is none. Independent thought, none.

H. G. Wells on Metropolis (1927) (via MeFi)

Tags: Classics Metropolis Review ScienceFiction Vintage


Wowcast 78: Black Mirror – 3x1/2/3: Nosedive, Playtest, Shut up and dance

Im 78. Wowcast besprechen wir die ersten drei Episoden – Nosedive, Playtest und Shut up and dance – der besten…


Wowcast 76: Westworld 1x02 – Chestnut

Im 76. Wowcast besprechen wir die zweite Folge Chestnut von HBOs Serien-Remake/Sequel von Michael Crichtons Westworld und sind, wie bereits…


Wowcast 75: Westworld 1x01 – The Original

Im 75. Wowcast nehmen wir die Pilotfolge von HBOs Serien-Remake/Sequel von Michael Crichtons Westworld auseinander. Sascha (@reeft, Facebook) und ich…


Mr. Plinketts The Star Wars Awakens Review

Red Letter Medias Mr. Plinkett returns to take down Cinematic Universes and Force Awakens. (via Sascha)


Fraktur sucks

Aus den Tweeties des hervorragenden Blogs Haggard Hawks („about obscure words and their origins“): „Mediaeval scribes invented this bizarre Latin…


Buster Keaton does The Twilight Zone: Once upon a Time

TIL: Es gibt eine Twilight Zone-Folge mit Buster Keaton. Ich habe von der alten Original-Serie bislang nur die erste Staffel…


Dawson City: Frozen Time – 100 Jahre alter Film aus Permafrost-Ausgrabung

Faszinierende Doku von Bill Morrison, der für Dawson City: Frozen Time Szene aus 100 Jahre alten Filmrollen montierte, die während…


1st computer-generated Music by Alan Turing restored

In Neuseeland haben sie Alan Turings 1951er Musik-Experimente restauriert. Die Melodien (God Save the King, das Kinderlied Baa, Baa Black…


Happy 50th, Star Trek! 🖖

Heute vor 50 Jahren flimmerte die erste Star Trek-Folge auf CBS über die Mattscheibe der Fernsehbildempfangsgeräte, in Deutschland war Raumschiff…


J.G.Ballard: Four Text Collages, 1958

Beautiful early Cut-Ups by J.G.Ballard at the British Library: J G Ballard created this series of four graphically experimental text…


Reviews: The Childhood of a Leader, I am not a Serial Killer, Blood Father, Bite, The Dead Room, Kickboxer: Vengeance

Letzte Woche weggeguckt, von gut nach schlecht. Knaller: I am not a Serial Killer, The Childhood of a Leader. Gut:…